Alberta ( Canada) votes to restrict newcomers’ access to health care and schools, early results show

CTN News
Categories: IMMIGRATION Politics
Albertans gather at a pro-Canada rally outside the provincial legislature in Edmonton on October 18, a day before the province’s non-binding referendum on Alberta sovereignty. (Photograph: Todd Korol/Reuters)

Voters in the Canadian province of Alberta have endorsed proposals to restrict some migrant workers’ and other newcomers’ access to publicly funded health care, education and social support, according to unofficial results from a referendum held October 19 and reported by The Guardian. The same vote rejected a question on separating from Canada, along with a set of proposed constitutional changes.

The result is non-binding, and the province cannot carry out the restrictions on its own. But it has sharpened a tension at the center of Alberta’s approach to immigration: even as the oil-rich province recruits workers from abroad to fill labor shortages, its government now wants to limit the services available to some of those same workers, The Guardian reported, in an account by Leyland Cecco.

The referendum put several immigration measures to voters.

One asked whether eligibility for provincially funded programs such as health care and education should be limited to Canadian citizens, permanent residents and “individuals with an Alberta-approved immigration status.” Another asked whether people with non-permanent immigration status should have to live in Alberta for 12 months before qualifying for certain social-support programs, and whether the province should be able to charge some temporary residents fees for health care and education. A March 2026 poll by Leger found roughly two-thirds support for those measures, with about a quarter opposed.

Governing United Conservative Party officials have argued that rapid population growth has overwhelmed hospitals and schools. Premier Danielle Smith earlier blamed the immigration policy of the former federal Liberal government for the strain, and in a social-media post wrote, “For every $1 of taxes a guest worker generates, taxpayers are covering $10 in services. This is not sustainable,” according to The Guardian. The province has said that temporary residents, who make up almost 6 percent of Alberta’s population, contribute roughly $150 million in tax revenue but cost more than $1 billion a year in health, education and other services.

- Advertisement -
Ad imageAd image

Those figures are contested. The Calgary writer Ximena González told The Guardian there is no data to support the province’s claim. The economist Gillian Petit noted that temporary residents also pay federal taxes that help fund Alberta’s health care, meaning they likely contribute more than the province acknowledges; if they pay less in total than other Albertans, she said, it is because they earn less than the median resident, and they are also less likely than the average Albertan to use health and education services.

Critics also questioned what the vote actually represents.

The economist Jim Stanford told The Guardian that hundreds of thousands of voters answered only the separation question and skipped the immigration ones, and that the outcome “cannot remotely be interpreted as a mandate for the government to crack down on immigration.” He described it as “a symbolic ideological exercise” that lends “a cast of legitimacy” to nativist sentiment on the province’s political right, and noted that Alberta does not have the power to act on the proposals unilaterally.

That limit is central. Federal ministers have said immigration is a shared federal-provincial responsibility. Emergency Management Minister Eleanor Olszewski said Ottawa was open to discussions and that “we are already engaged in those discussions,” while Immigration Minister Lena Metlege Diab said the federal government was already doing much of what the questions described through its immigration-levels plan, CP24 reported. Prime Minister Mark Carney, campaigning in Calgary before the vote, urged Albertans to vote “No to the Nine,” referring to the nine non-separation questions. The federal government has already trimmed national immigration targets and tightened the Temporary Foreign Worker program amid complaints it was being misused by large employers.

Alberta’s economy depends heavily on foreign labor in sectors such as agriculture, food services and tourism, where employers struggle to recruit and retain staff, and the UCP government had previously invested in recruitment and expanded the province’s immigration nomination targets. The proposals mark a reversal that the workers affected describe in personal terms.

Vanesa Ortiz, who came to Calgary from Mexico a decade ago, now teaches and works with the nonprofit Asociación de Mexicanos en Calgary.

She told The Guardian she feared the measures would push workers “into the shadows” and make them more vulnerable to exploitation, noting that thousands of farm workers in the province already go without health care. “Scapegoating non-permanent residents is not going to lower the cost of living,” she said. “In many cases, they are frontline workers. And now they’re being treated as disposable.” She called the government’s shift a “betrayal” of people “who work, study and raise their children here.”

- Advertisement -
Ad imageAd image

González, who arrived in Canada 16 years ago as an international student, was blunter about the message she heard. “We wanted you to come, to exploit you. And now, we don’t need you any more — so we will punish you,” she said, characterizing the government’s posture. She also faulted news coverage for fixating on the separation question while the immigration measures drew little scrutiny.

The sentiment was not confined to the ballot. The Guardian reported that at government-led town halls over the years, some residents voiced far harsher views — one drew cheers for proposing mass deportations, and another claimed immigrants “harm” children. As the official count continues, the practical effect of the vote will depend less on the result itself than on what, if anything, the province can negotiate with a federal government that holds much of the authority over immigration.

Albertans gather at a pro-Canada rally outside the provincial legislature in Edmonton on October 18, a day before the province’s non-binding referendum on Alberta sovereignty. (Photograph: Todd Korol/Reuters)

Source: The Guardian
https://ctninfo.com/?p=45058&preview=true

AI Use Policy:

Some of CTN’s journalists are not native English speakers and draft their work in French or Haitian Creole. We then use AI-assisted translation software to produce the English versions, and traces of machine-generated phrasing may occasionally remain. Every article — in any language — is written, reviewed, and edited by CTN’s staff writers and editors, who remain responsible for its accuracy. CTN also uses AI to convert text into audio.

Share This Article