Federal prosecutors in Western Washington have told the court they will no longer defend Immigration and Customs Enforcement in many of the detention lawsuits now flooding the district’s dockets, citing a shortage of attorneys to keep pace with the volume.
The decision was laid out in an October 26 letter from Acting U.S. Attorney Charles Floyd to Chief U.S. District Judge David S. Estudillo of the Western District of Washington. The letter was first reported by Law and Crime and later detailed by the Associated Press, Newsweek, and CNN. In it, Floyd wrote that his office does not have the staff to answer the steady stream of habeas corpus petitions filed by people who say ICE is holding them unlawfully.
“The USAO unfortunately does not have the available resources, at this juncture, to continue entering AUSA appearances in every one of the dozens of §2241 Immigration Petitions filed each week,” Floyd wrote, using the federal statute under which detainees challenge their confinement. “Thus, going forward, to conserve resources, there will be many habeas cases in which the USAO will no longer assume responsibility for providing a defense on behalf of the respondents.”
The letter sets a firm clock. If the government does not file a notice of appearance within seven court days, the court may proceed to rule on the merits of a petition without a defense from the government. In those cases, prosecutors will not help move the case forward or act as an intermediary between the court and ICE. Floyd’s letter went further, encouraging the court to email an ICE detention facility in Tacoma directly when a detained immigrant is ordered released, according to reporting by CNN.
Floyd stopped short of withdrawing entirely. His office said it will keep reviewing new petitions and scheduling orders as they arrive, continue forwarding those orders to the appropriate ICE contacts, and reserve the right to re-enter any case it decides warrants a government defense. The office framed the policy as a way to conserve resources rather than a blanket refusal to participate.
A caseload that outran the office
The surge traces back to an earlier shift in administration policy. Under the change, immigrant detainees seeking release could no longer rely on the immigration system to secure it quickly and instead had to file habeas corpus petitions asking a federal judge to order their release — a requirement that applied even to people with no violent history, CNN reported. The number of such filings climbed sharply.
The scale is substantial. The Western District of Washington alone had handled roughly 2,000 habeas cases as of earlier this month, according to ProPublica. Nationwide, more than 93,000 immigration-related habeas cases have been filed since January, Newsweek reported, and border czar Tom Homan told Fox News last week that the courts were weighed down by roughly 85,000 such cases.
To manage the load, the court had earlier adopted a specialized scheduling process meant to bring uniformity and speed to the petitions. Floyd’s office acknowledged that the process improved consistency but said it also drove a continuous rise in filings — now dozens each week — while consuming time its attorneys needed for status reports, supplemental briefing, motions tied to the Equal Access to Justice Act, and responses to court orders arising from technical scheduling issues. That work, the office said, has cut into its ability to handle unrelated civil litigation across the district.
Already taking effect
The policy’s practical consequence surfaced quickly. U.S. District Judge Tiffany Cartwright ordered the release of Baljit Singh, an asylum seeker from India who was held at the Northwest ICE Processing Center in Tacoma, after no government lawyer entered an appearance within the seven-day window. Cartwright treated the matter as “intentionally unopposed,” citing the parameters set out in Floyd’s October 26 letter, according to reporting on her order. Court records show at least one additional petition has been granted without opposition since the letter was filed.
The shift puts more control over detainee releases in the hands of the District Court, which covers a region of more than 6 million people and includes Tacoma and Olympia. Judges in the district have frequently ruled against the government in cases brought by detainees who argue their confinement is unlawful.
Floyd, a former immigration judge, has been aligned with the administration’s broader detention posture. He and three other Washington judges had advocated for barring immigration courts from granting bond to detainees — a question now before the U.S. Supreme Court, the Associated Press reported. Immigrant rights advocates, for their part, have been sharply critical of the policies that generated the wave of petitions in the first place.
https://ctninfo.com/?p=45337&preview=true
https://www.facebook.com/CaribbeanNewsMedia

AI Use Policy:
CTN uses artificial intelligence tools to support research, drafting, and editing. All content is reviewed and verified by a human editor before publication. Reporting in this article draws on Law and Crime, the Associated Press, Newsweek, CNN, and ProPublica, and on court records in the Western District of Washington.


